Overwhelmingly though, my sense is that different though they are, one is neither better nor worse than the other. I might struggle if I were transported overnight into Ivan’s world, and he would if he were transported into mine, but that has less to do with material notions of success and more with values. By far the greatest challenge for me would be to maintain Ivan’s standards of moral purpose; he eats no meat or animal produce of any kind, indeed uses nothing that is derived from an animal. He gives a significant percentage of his income to charity, even though he lives on a meagre income and has nothing left over at the end of each month. He is kind and generous to everyone, sees no one as responsible for his life and has no sense grievance to society for how the world has treated him. Indeed, quite the opposite; he regularly says he feels blessed and that there are a great many people with far more difficult lives than he. In a world where victimhood and grievance politics has taken hold like a weed, it is quite remarkable to hear him speak in such generous and conciliatory tones. I’m not sure who, in this country at least, would count as having a worse lot than Ivan save for those teetering on the very edge of life itself. Again though, that perspective is based on a very rigid set of value and parameters for what a ‘successful life’ looks like. Ivan’s perspective is eye opening, challenging and rewarding to hear and engage with.
Our lives are very different, but I aspire to be more like Ivan